Custom Cabinets
Lancaster, PA

Our shop is in Honey Brook, a small community on Route 322 between Lancaster and Chester County. We are not a national chain with a showroom here. We are a Lancaster County company that has been building custom Amish cabinetry in this region since 1979.

Levi Stoltzfus founded Choice Custom Cabinetry and Design here, in the heart of Pennsylvania Amish country. His sons Steve and Leo run it today. The craftsmen who build every cabinet in our 20,000 square foot Honey Brook facility are part of the same community. When you work with us, you are working with the people who built your neighbors’ kitchens, sometimes decades ago, and sometimes last month.

We build cabinetry for kitchens, bathrooms, living rooms, home offices, mudrooms, pantries, and wine rooms. Every project starts with a blank page and a conversation about what you want, not a catalog of options to choose from.

See completed Lancaster County projects across kitchens, bathrooms, and living spaces in our project gallery. For the full range of cabinetry we offer, visit our services page.

Lancaster County has an unusually diverse housing stock. You have 18th and 19th century colonial and farmhouse construction, Victorian-era homes in borough centers, mid-century ranches and split-levels in the suburban townships, and newer construction in developments throughout the county. Each type presents different cabinet challenges.

Stone farmhouses, bank barns converted to living space, and colonial-era homes often have ceiling heights that are not standard, walls that are not plumb after 200 years of settling, and floor levels that vary by an inch across a single room. Standard-sized cabinets from a showroom require filler strips and compromise the finish. Custom cabinets built to the actual measurements of the room fit correctly and look like they belong there.

The Victorian and early 20th-century rowhouses and detached homes in Lancaster City, Lititz, Ephrata, and Manheim often have kitchens that were added or renovated at various points and have unusual proportions. These rooms benefit most from custom work because the dimensions simply do not follow any standard module.

The developments in Mount Joy, Elizabethtown, Strasburg, Quarryville, and New Holland tend to have standard dimensions and are often well-suited to our semi-custom line: the same solid hardwood construction and dovetail drawers as full custom, in standard sizing increments that fit these kitchens at a lower price point. See our semi-custom cabinet shop for options and lead times.

We build and install throughout Lancaster County and the surrounding region. Our Honey Brook shop is within 30 minutes of most Lancaster County communities, which means site visits are easy to arrange and installation logistics are straightforward.

We also serve Chester County, Berks County, Lebanon County, York County, and the Philadelphia area regularly. For projects outside Lancaster County, travel time is factored into the project plan. Read more about our service area on our about page.

Working with a local cabinet maker is simpler than most people expect. Here is how a project moves from first contact to finished installation.

We will give you real numbers. Full custom Amish kitchen cabinets from our shop run $15,000 to $45,000 installed for most Lancaster County kitchens, depending on size, wood species, door style, and layout complexity. Larger kitchens with premium materials go above that.

These are complete installed prices including design, materials, production, finishing, delivery, and installation. Countertops, appliances, plumbing, and electrical are separate.

Our semi-custom line starts considerably lower for standard-dimension kitchens and produces the same solid hardwood quality in less time. For a full breakdown of what drives cost up or down and what each price level actually delivers, see our Pennsylvania cabinet pricing guide. The most accurate number for your specific project comes from a consultation with your room measured.